Design Miter Tile Logo


Fathers Day Special: Get 25% off Select Silestone Slabs

Victorian Home with Granite or Marble Countertops

Marble vs. Granite Countertops Showdown

Victorian design is known for its opulence, intricacy, and grandeur. A key element in capturing the essence of this era is choosing the right material for countertops. Both marble and granite are highly sought-after choices for creating a luxurious Victorian aesthetic. In this article, we will present a detailed comparison of these two countertop materials, highlighting their characteristics, pros, and cons. By examining these factors, we aim to help readers make informed decisions based on their preferences and lifestyle.

Characteristics Comparison

Before delving into the pros and cons, let’s compare the main characteristics of marble and granite countertops.


  • Elegant and timeless appearance with unique veining patterns
  • Soft, porous stone susceptible to stains and scratches
  • Smooth and cool to the touch
  • Varied color options, including white, gray, green, and black


  • Durable and resistant to heat and scratches
  • Natural stone with coarse texture and flecks of minerals
  • Wide range of colors, such as black, brown, beige, and red
  • Less prone to staining compared to marble, but still requires sealing

Now that we have an overview of the characteristics, let’s dive deeper into the pros and cons of each material.

Pros & Cons of Marble Countertops

Marble is often associated with luxury due to its rich history and distinctive appearance. However, it is crucial to consider its advantages and drawbacks before making a decision.

Marble Countertop Pros

Timeless Elegance: The veining patterns of marble exude elegance, capturing the essence of Victorian opulence. Whether you choose classic white Carrara marble or rare Calacatta marble, it instantly elevates the overall aesthetic of any space.

Unique Beauty: No two marble slabs are exactly alike. Each piece possesses its own intricate veining, making it highly desirable for those seeking a one-of-a-kind countertop.

Heat Resistance: Marble is a naturally cool stone, which makes it an ideal surface for baking and working with pastry dough. Additionally, it exhibits good resistance to heat, reducing the risk of damage from hot pots and pans.

Marble Countertops Cons

Porosity: Marble is a porous stone, making it vulnerable to staining from acidic substances such as wine, coffee, and citrus juices. To minimize this risk, regular sealing is necessary.

Scratches and Etching: Due to its softness, marble is prone to scratches and etching caused by sharp objects, abrasive cleaners, or even acidic spills. Careful consideration should be given to how the countertop will be used to avoid unwanted damage.

Maintenance: Marble requires extra care and maintenance compared to other materials. It needs to be regularly cleaned with non-abrasive products, sealed periodically, and protected from potential damage.

Pros & Cons of Granite Countertops

Granite countertops have gained immense popularity in recent years due to their durability, natural beauty, and wide range of color options. Let’s examine the pros and cons of choosing granite for your Victorian-inspired kitchen or bathroom.

Granite Countertop Pros

Durability: Granite is renowned for its strength and resistance to scratches, heat, and impacts. It can withstand heavy daily use, making it an excellent choice for busy kitchens.

Low Maintenance: Unlike marble, granite is less porous, requiring minimal maintenance and sealing. This characteristic also makes it more resistant to staining caused by spills.

Varied Color Palette: With a vast assortment of colors and patterns, granite offers endless options to suit various design preferences. From classic black and white combinations to bolder hues like red and blue, there is a granite slab to complement any Victorian aesthetic.

Granite Countertop Cons

Uniformity: Unlike marble’s unique veining, granite typically exhibits a more uniform appearance. While some may appreciate this consistency, others may find it lacking in character or individuality.

Coarse Texture: Granite can have a textured surface due to its natural mineral composition. For those looking for a sleek and smooth countertop, the texture of granite might not meet their expectations.

Cost: Compared to other countertop materials, granite tends to be more expensive. However, when considering its durability and long lifespan, it can be viewed as a worthwhile investment.

Conclusion: Choosing between Marble and Granite for your Victorian Home

In the quest to create a Victorian opulent ambiance, selecting the right countertop material is crucial. Both marble and granite offer unique characteristics, pros, and cons that should be carefully considered. Marble brings timeless elegance and a one-of-a-kind beauty, but requires regular maintenance and is prone to staining. On the other hand, granite provides durability, a wide variety of color options, and lower maintenance requirements, though it may lack the distinctive veining patterns of marble.

Ultimately, the choice between marble and granite countertops depends on your personal preferences and lifestyle. If you prioritize uniqueness and can commit to regular maintenance, marble may be the perfect choice. Meanwhile, if durability, low maintenance, and a wealth of color options are your key considerations, granite could be the ideal fit for your Victorian-inspired space.

At Design Miter Tile, we understand the importance of making informed decisions when selecting countertop materials. We offer a wide range of marble and granite options, along with expert guidance to help you find the perfect fit for your Victorian design. Visit our store in Campbell, CA, to explore our collection and bring the opulence of Victorian design to your home.

Frequently Asked Questions about granite and marble countertops in Victorian Homes

Are marble countertops more expensive than granite?

While individual prices may vary depending on factors such as quality and rarity, in general, marble tends to be more expensive than granite due to its luxurious reputation and unique veining patterns.

Granite is a highly durable material that is resistant to most impacts. However, extreme force or heavy objects dropped directly on the edges of a granite countertop can potentially cause chips or cracks. Proper care should be taken to avoid such incidents.

Marble countertops generally require more frequent sealing compared to granite, typically every 6 to 12 months. Granite, being less porous, typically only needs to be sealed every 1 to 3 years. However, the exact frequency of sealing can vary depending on usage and the specific sealant used. It’s recommended to consult with a professional for guidance.

Scroll to Top